Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
  • National Security
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Europe
    • Estonia
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Moldova
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • Ukraine
  • Counterterrorism
  • Cybersecurity
  • Intelligence

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest National Security News directly to your inbox.

What's Hot

Вже зараз потрібна принципова відповідь міжнародної спільноти на російські удари по Запорізькій АЕС – звернення Президента України

August 7, 2022

Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt Saeimas vēlēšanās ģimenes apstākļu dēļ

August 7, 2022

Unde activează fostul vicepremier pe Reintegrare, Vladislav Kulminski

August 7, 2022
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact
Sunday, August 7
Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
  • National Security
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Europe
    • Estonia
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Moldova
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • Ukraine
  • Counterterrorism
  • Cybersecurity
  • Intelligence
en English
en Englishet Estonianlv Latvianlt Lithuanianpl Polishro Romanianru Russianuk Ukrainian
Trending
  • Вже зараз потрібна принципова відповідь міжнародної спільноти на російські удари по Запорізькій АЕС – звернення Президента України
  • Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt Saeimas vēlēšanās ģimenes apstākļu dēļ
  • Unde activează fostul vicepremier pe Reintegrare, Vladislav Kulminski
  • Thatcher’s energy secretary says Tory leadership contenders’ response to price spike ‘inadequate’
  • Negotiators optimistic about progress on Iran nuclear deal
  • Jos sau nu guvernarea? Expert: Vom vedea situația când vor fi proteste
  • Ce cadouri a primit prim-ministra de la diferiți oficiali
  • Beijing continuing to send warships, aircraft toward Taiwan after Pelosi visit
Subscribe
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
Home » How can the US and NATO help bring about Russia’s ‘strategic failure’ in Ukraine?

How can the US and NATO help bring about Russia’s ‘strategic failure’ in Ukraine?

May 11, 20225 Mins Read United States
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email
This article is part of the Transatlantic Security Initiative’s Stronger with Allies series, which charts the course forward for the Alliance in conjunction with the 2022 NATO Summit.

With Ukraine having repelled Russian forces near Kyiv, the Kremlin’s war of aggression has entered a new phase: a more limited offensive in eastern Ukraine. As the United States and its transatlantic allies and partners formulate fresh strategies for what will likely be a protracted conflict, there are several factors they must consider, senior officials and experts said at a recent Atlantic Council event.

The US objective is Russian “strategic failure”—militarily, politically and economically— US Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs Celeste Wallander said at the May 2 conference, titled “Priorities for the NATO Summit and Security in Europe.” That would involve in the long term “holding the Russian leadership to account in front of its own population and in front of the global stage,” she said. Wallander’s comments expanded on US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin’s recent statement that the United States “want[s] to see Russia weakened to the degree that it can’t do the kinds of things that it has done in invading Ukraine.”

What Russian accountability will look like is unclear at this point. However, US Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC), speaking at the conference, argued that the United States has to “look ahead to a regime change before we could ever have anything in the way of a productive working relationship with Russia,” and describing Russian President Vladimir Putin as “not fit to serve.”

At the same time, Michael Kofman, research program director at the Russia Studies Program of CNA, cautioned against treating Russia’s comprehensive strategic failure in the war as a foregone conclusion. Indeed, the “trend lines favor Ukraine,” he said. However, changes in Russia’s tactics such as full mobilization could lead to a longer, more drawn-out conflict, Kofman added, addressing the event ahead of the NATO summit scheduled for late June.

The United States and NATO must not learn the wrong lessons from the war, he said. The Russian military, despite taking a beating so far, still presents a real threat. “I’m worried that I’m going to have to spend a lot of years now arguing that [the Russian military] isn’t four feet tall,” said Kofman. When it comes to new defense investments, Alliance members should also avoid relying on broad conclusions about the effectiveness of capabilities in Ukraine, warned former Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen (Ret.) James Cartwright.

The United States and NATO allies need to continue and expand their supply of ammunition and heavier artillery weapons that have been a key part of Ukrainian battlefield success against Russia, according to Kofman. Yet, nations supplying Ukraine must also take care that they do not deplete their own stocks of critical weapons systems too much, with the pipeline to produce and replace advanced weapons sent to Ukraine being “quite narrow” in many cases, as described by Kofman. The United States can play a critical role here as the “arsenal of democracy,” harking back to the role it played in World War II, some speakers suggested. US Senator Chris Murphy (D-CT) said that the United States was “going to have to look at ramping up production… to make sure that all of our allies have what they need” to supply Ukraine while maintaining their own supplies.

The Alliance will also need to make major adjustments to its strategy and posture in Eastern Europe, speakers said. Already, allies have shifted significant forces further east, making NATO’s conventional deterrence “the strongest that it has been… in our lifetimes” according to US Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy, Plans, and Capabilities Mara Karlin. Former Supreme Allied Commander Europe Gen (Ret.) Philip M. Breedlove added that NATO has to be ready to “seize the moment” and “move readiness and capability forward” in Europe. More ready and capable forces, including persistent, rotational US deployments to Eastern Europe will help move NATO from a deterrence by punishment posture to deterrence by denial, making it harder for any future Russian attack to take and hold NATO territory.

NATO will also move to finalize its new Strategic Concept this summer, the first new guiding strategy for the Alliance since 2010. “The 2022 edition will definitely be the most challenging,” said Alexander Vershbow, Atlantic Council distinguished fellow, former NATO deputy secretary general, and former US ambassador to Russia. Vershbow agreed with Breedlove, saying that the Strategic Concept should revamp NATO’s defense and deterrence posture by shifting more forces forward. Many of these forces, if and when they are deployed, will go to the Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania—frontline nations that are some of the Alliance’s most vulnerable members. These countries have long been advocates for increased allied presence in the region. Speaking at the conference, Lithuanian Minister of National Defense Arvydas Anušauskas highlighted increased spending by the country on facilities to enable it to host larger numbers of allied forces in the future.

Throughout the discussion, panelists emphasized that the conflict and the new strategic circumstances that Russia has created in Europe will shape the security dynamic there for the foreseeable future, and the Untied States and its allies in NATO will need to remain focused and united to adapt to this challenge and ensure Russia meets strategic failure. In the words of Michael Kofman, “Security in Europe is an unfinished business, and to me this conflict reflects that.”

Watch the full event



Connor McPartland is an assistant director with the Atlantic Council’s Transatlantic Security Initiative, part of the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email

Articles Liés

Negotiators optimistic about progress on Iran nuclear deal

August 7, 2022 United States

Beijing continuing to send warships, aircraft toward Taiwan after Pelosi visit

August 7, 2022 United States

China keeps up pressure on Taiwan with 4th day of drills

August 7, 2022 United States

Israeli airstrike kills Khaled Mansour, 2nd top Islamic Jihad commander

August 7, 2022 United States

Donald Trump urges against GOP complacency in CPAC speech

August 6, 2022 United States

The misnamed Inflation Reduction Act: A pointless giveaway to special interests

August 6, 2022 United States
Don't Miss
Latvia

Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt Saeimas vēlēšanās ģimenes apstākļu dēļ

By woe whAugust 7, 20220

“Konservatīvo” frakcijas deputāte Dagmāra Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt 14.Saeimas vēlēšanās vīra veselības dēļ, sarunā…

Unde activează fostul vicepremier pe Reintegrare, Vladislav Kulminski

August 7, 2022

Thatcher’s energy secretary says Tory leadership contenders’ response to price spike ‘inadequate’

August 7, 2022

Negotiators optimistic about progress on Iran nuclear deal

August 7, 2022
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Vimeo
Our Picks

Ce cadouri a primit prim-ministra de la diferiți oficiali

August 7, 2022

Beijing continuing to send warships, aircraft toward Taiwan after Pelosi visit

August 7, 2022

Thousands of infected blood victims to receive £100,000 compensation

August 7, 2022

Penny Mordaunt claims Liz Truss ‘misinterpreted’ after dismissing cost of living ‘handouts’

August 7, 2022

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest National Security News directly to your inbox.

© 2022 Estonian Free Press. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.