Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
  • National Security
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Europe
    • Estonia
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Moldova
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • Ukraine
  • Counterterrorism
  • Cybersecurity
  • Intelligence

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest National Security News directly to your inbox.

What's Hot

Вже зараз потрібна принципова відповідь міжнародної спільноти на російські удари по Запорізькій АЕС – звернення Президента України

August 7, 2022

Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt Saeimas vēlēšanās ģimenes apstākļu dēļ

August 7, 2022

Unde activează fostul vicepremier pe Reintegrare, Vladislav Kulminski

August 7, 2022
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact
Sunday, August 7
Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
  • National Security
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Europe
    • Estonia
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Moldova
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • Ukraine
  • Counterterrorism
  • Cybersecurity
  • Intelligence
en English
en Englishet Estonianlv Latvianlt Lithuanianpl Polishro Romanianru Russianuk Ukrainian
Trending
  • Вже зараз потрібна принципова відповідь міжнародної спільноти на російські удари по Запорізькій АЕС – звернення Президента України
  • Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt Saeimas vēlēšanās ģimenes apstākļu dēļ
  • Unde activează fostul vicepremier pe Reintegrare, Vladislav Kulminski
  • Thatcher’s energy secretary says Tory leadership contenders’ response to price spike ‘inadequate’
  • Negotiators optimistic about progress on Iran nuclear deal
  • Jos sau nu guvernarea? Expert: Vom vedea situația când vor fi proteste
  • Ce cadouri a primit prim-ministra de la diferiți oficiali
  • Beijing continuing to send warships, aircraft toward Taiwan after Pelosi visit
Subscribe
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
Home » Adviser says court should dismiss legal challenge to linking EU money with rule of law

Adviser says court should dismiss legal challenge to linking EU money with rule of law

December 2, 20214 Mins Read Europe
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

The legal adviser of the top EU court said on Thursday (2 December) Budapest and Warsaw’s legal challenges to the EU law that links disbursement of bloc funds to rule of law standards should be dismissed.

The arguments brought by Hungary and Poland against the so-called “regime of conditionality” protecting the EU budget, adopted last December as part of a compromise deal between EU-27 leaders, failed to convince advocate general Manuel Campos Sánchez-Bordona.

The mechanism, under which countries with systemic rule of law problems could lose out on EU funds, posed a major hurdle in the wider negotiations on the bloc’s historic €1.8 trillion budget, partly aimed at helping the post-pandemic economic recovery, at the end of last year.

The compromise hammered out by the European leaders, under which Hungary and Poland agreed to unblock the budget, included a provision that the European Court of Justice (ECJ), the bloc’s highest court, must first rule on whether the mechanism falls foul of EU treaties.

Weak legal arguments

In the opinion of the ECJ’s legal expert, whose positions are not binding though are very often followed by the justices in their final ruling, the arguments of Hungary and Poland failed to convince.

In Campos Sánchez-Bordona’s view, the EU treaties article that was relied on to pass the regulation was chosen correctly as the law calls for “a sufficiently direct link” between the budget and rule of law breaches, and as such “constitutes a financial rule”.

The advocate general also dismissed the arguments that the mechanism was simply a way to implement sanctions similar to those provided in the so-called Article 7 process, where in the final stages, EU countries breaching bloc values can lose their voting rights if other club members unanimously agree, but with looser procedural requirements.

Both Hungary and Poland have been in the process for years, but the highly political procedure has been stuck in the Council.

EU leaders offer no way out of Polish rule of law crisis

EU leaders failed to offer a way forward on Poland’s challenge on European legal order in a “serene” discussion that barely lasted two hours on Thursday (21 October), a relatively short meeting by EU summit standards.

Campos Sánchez-Bordona said that not only did Article 7 not preclude the introduction of other instruments that protect values, but the conditionality law was compatible with the EU treaties because it was more specific and sought to protect one of the values “which affect[s] budgetary management”.

Finally, the advocate general also threw out the allegation that the “breaches of the principles of the rule of law” was too vague.

Campos Sánchez-Bordona pointed to the seven principles listed in the regulation, as well as the indicative list of what could constitute breaches, concluding this satisfied “the minimum requirements for clarity, precision and foreseeability required by the principle of legal certainty.”

While the Court does not comment on judgement dates well in advance, the final ruling is expected for early 2022.

Back and forth

The legal opinion represents another step in the ongoing rule of law disputes between Brussels and Budapest and Warsaw.

Last year’s compromise budget deal also included a controversial promise by the European Commission that it would not activate the procedure against any country until it had put guidelines in place governing its use, and a promise that it will wait for the outcome of the court case concerning the regulation.

The EU executive has sent information letters under the conditionality regulation, seen by EURACTIV, on 19 November, asking Budapest and Warsaw to explain problems in public procurement, ineffective prosecutions, judicial independence and following EU court rulings.

The two capitals now have two months to respond, a deadline likely to coincide roughly with the outcome of the EU Court ruling.

Meanwhile, frustrated lawmakers in the European parliament, who have criticised the Commission for dragging its feet, managed to mount their own legal case, albeit a weak one in the view of experts, against the EU executive for “failure to act”.

[Edited by Zoran Radosavljevic]

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email

Articles Liés

Italy finalises justice reform to help unlock EU funding

August 5, 2022 Europe

Italian police seize assets from architect linked to ‘Putin’s Black Sea palace’

August 4, 2022 Europe

European court rejects appeal as British parents fight to keep son’s life support

August 4, 2022 Europe

Med migrant rescue charities call for EU help

August 3, 2022 Europe

Steadicopter to Supply BLACK EAGLE to Israeli Navy

August 1, 2022 Europe

KMW & Elbit Sign Rocket Cooperation Agreement

July 29, 2022 Europe
Don't Miss
Latvia

Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt Saeimas vēlēšanās ģimenes apstākļu dēļ

By woe whAugust 7, 20220

“Konservatīvo” frakcijas deputāte Dagmāra Beitnere-Le Galla pieņēmusi lēmumu nekandidēt 14.Saeimas vēlēšanās vīra veselības dēļ, sarunā…

Unde activează fostul vicepremier pe Reintegrare, Vladislav Kulminski

August 7, 2022

Thatcher’s energy secretary says Tory leadership contenders’ response to price spike ‘inadequate’

August 7, 2022

Negotiators optimistic about progress on Iran nuclear deal

August 7, 2022
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Vimeo
Our Picks

Ce cadouri a primit prim-ministra de la diferiți oficiali

August 7, 2022

Beijing continuing to send warships, aircraft toward Taiwan after Pelosi visit

August 7, 2022

Most Americans think the U.S. economy is getting worse: poll

August 7, 2022

Thousands of infected blood victims to receive £100,000 compensation

August 7, 2022

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest National Security News directly to your inbox.

© 2022 Estonian Free Press. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.