Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
  • National Security
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Europe
    • Estonia
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Moldova
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • Ukraine
  • Counterterrorism
  • Cybersecurity
  • Intelligence

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest National Security News directly to your inbox.

What's Hot

‘Overwhelmed’ food banks forced to turn people away after running out of food

August 14, 2022

Keir Starmer unveils £29bn Labour plan to freeze energy price cap

August 14, 2022

Що сильнішою буде Україна, то слабшою буде Росія і менше триватиме ця війна – звернення Президента Володимира Зеленського

August 14, 2022
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact
Monday, August 15
Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
  • National Security
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Europe
    • Estonia
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Moldova
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • Ukraine
  • Counterterrorism
  • Cybersecurity
  • Intelligence
en English
en Englishet Estonianlv Latvianlt Lithuanianpl Polishro Romanianru Russianuk Ukrainian
Trending
  • ‘Overwhelmed’ food banks forced to turn people away after running out of food
  • Keir Starmer unveils £29bn Labour plan to freeze energy price cap
  • Що сильнішою буде Україна, то слабшою буде Росія і менше триватиме ця війна – звернення Президента Володимира Зеленського
  • Blissfully unaware in Vermont or knowingly radical?
  • Why are no Democrats prosecuted by Garland’s DOJ?
  • Popular wild walrus euthanized by Norwegian authorities
  • Popescu: Suntem foarte îngrijorați de atacurile din Zaporojie
  • Government must ‘overrule nimbys’ on new reservoirs, says infrastructure tsar
Subscribe
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Estonian Free PressEstonian Free Press
Home » EU adopts law giving tech giants one hour to remove terrorist content

EU adopts law giving tech giants one hour to remove terrorist content

April 28, 20215 Mins Read Cybersecurity
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

The European Parliament on Wednesday (28 April) formally adopted without a vote controversial legislation which forces online platforms to remove terrorist content within an hour of it being flagged.

The regulation on preventing the dissemination of terrorist content online, which was adopted in the face of opposition from several organisations and MEPs, includes an obligation for digital platforms to remove “terrorist content or disable access to terrorist content in all member states as soon as possible and in any event within one hour of receipt of the removal order.”

These “removal orders” must come from the “competent authority” of each EU country and can be addressed to all member states.

The legislation, which was drafted by the European Commission in the wake of a series of terror attacks across the bloc, is seen as necessary to combat online content disseminated by terrorists to spread their message, radicalise and recruit followers, and direct terrorist activities.

However, critics say that giving platform hosts such a short deadline would encourage them to use algorithms for their moderation. Furthermore, an absence of judicial control and the transnational scope of the removal orders threatens freedom of expression and represents a danger for democracy, they say.

The latest open letter to MEPs calling on them to reject the legislation points “to the contradictions of this text with the decision of the French Constitutional Council of 18 June 2020 on the law to combat hateful content on the internet”.

The Constitutional Council rejected several provisions of the so-called Avia law which would have forced hosts to remove offending content within 24 hours on the grounds that “such a time limit is particularly short” and that the removal order provided for “is not subject to the prior intervention of a judge or to any other condition”.

Lucille Rouet of Syndicat de la Magistrature, one of the signatories to the letter, regrets that the European text presents the same risk as the provisions of the Avia law, that of “preventive withdrawals”.

“The risk is that too many things are withdrawn based on criteria that are too broad, so as not to be sanctioned,” she told EURACTIV.

Guarantees obtained

In light of the criticism, a number of safeguards were added to the proposed legislation. The text now states that “material disseminated for educational, journalistic, artistic or research purposes or for awareness-raising purposes against terrorist activity should not be considered to be terrorist content”.

A provision was also added to deal with the issue of platforms deploying automated filters. The regulation now states that “any requirement to take specific measures shall not include an obligation to use automated tools by the hosting service provider” and adds transparency obligations in this regard.

“The agreement that has been negotiated, from my point of view, seems balanced. Not ideal, but the conditions are guaranteed with regard to the main issues,” Sylvie Guillaume, a French MEP in the Group of the Progressive Alliance of Socialists and Democrats, told journalists earlier this week.

“I know that the French authorities had been lobbying us for several months to get this text voted on,” she added.

However, many remained unsatisfied with the concessions.

“To say that [using automated tools] is not an obligation is to allow it,” Green MEP Gwendoline Delbos-Corfield told EURACTIV, in a “context where the algorithm is going to be cheaper than human means”.

Platforms will no doubt choose this option in the face of the legal risks and the “moral pressure that will set in”, she added.

Meanwhile, questions remain about the practicality of removing content within an hour of it being flagged.

“The one-hour removal deadline will be nigh on impossible for most small platforms to implement effectively,” Jacob Berntsson, head of policy and research at the UN-backed Tech Against Terrorism initiative told EURACTIV.

“Given that terrorists exploit smaller platforms due to their lack of capacity and resources, this regulation therefore risks not only being ineffective in achieving its intended purpose, but also harming smaller platforms in the process,” he added.

The risk of ‘opportunism’

Green MEP Delbos-Corfield also said she feared “opportunism” on the part of some member states who may urge their neighbours to remove content without judicial review. “The term ‘terrorism’ is now being used all over the place, in everyone’s mouth, in a completely undue way,” she said.

“Hungary theorised that you were an enemy of the nation, which is not far from terrorist, when you criticised an element of the government,” said Delbos-Corfield, who is a member of Parliament’s Special Committee on Foreign Interference.

“If tomorrow Marine Le Pen comes to power [in France], she will be able to consider being an ultra-leftist as being a terrorist,” she added.

Privacy campaigner and fellow MEP Patrick Breyer agreed.

“Anti-terrorism legislation is again and again being abused for entirely different purposes such as to crack down on Spanish separatists and artists, French protesters or refugees in Hungary,” he said.

No vote in plenary

The legislation was not put to a vote in the plenary. Since the text as it stands was approved by the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs (LIBE) on 11 January by 52 votes in favour and 14 against, a new debate in the Chamber was ruled out.

Delbos-Corfield said the decision not to vote the legislation had left her feeling “immense regret.”

“Every time we avoid a democratic debate, we deprive ourselves of collective intelligence […] even if we don’t vote today, it’s not over yet,” she said.

France to decide whether to allow widespread retention of connection data

France’s Council of State, the country’s highest legal entity, is meeting on Friday (16 April) to finally decide whether to allow the widespread retention of connection data despite the Court of Justice in Luxembourg having already ruled against the practice several times. EURACTIV France reports.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email

Articles Liés

OIG: DHS Needs a Unified Strategy to Counter Disinformation

August 13, 2022 Cybersecurity

Why Proactive Cybersecurity Is a Must in Today’s Sophisticated Threat Environment

August 12, 2022 Cybersecurity

DISA Flags Contractors’ Inappropriate Use of Government Computers

August 11, 2022 Cybersecurity

CISA Releases Toolkit of Free Cybersecurity Resources for Election Community

August 10, 2022 Cybersecurity

U.S. Space Force Conducts Innovative Cyber Talent Acquisition Process

August 10, 2022 Cybersecurity

Information Enterprise Modernization Is an Important DoD Priority, Official Says

August 10, 2022 Cybersecurity
Don't Miss
United Kingdom

Keir Starmer unveils £29bn Labour plan to freeze energy price cap

By woe whAugust 14, 20220

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer has unveiled his plan to freeze the energy price cap,…

Що сильнішою буде Україна, то слабшою буде Росія і менше триватиме ця війна – звернення Президента Володимира Зеленського

August 14, 2022

Blissfully unaware in Vermont or knowingly radical?

August 14, 2022

Why are no Democrats prosecuted by Garland’s DOJ?

August 14, 2022
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Vimeo
Our Picks

Popescu: Suntem foarte îngrijorați de atacurile din Zaporojie

August 14, 2022

Government must ‘overrule nimbys’ on new reservoirs, says infrastructure tsar

August 14, 2022

Averea lui Sîrbu, învinuit de îmbogăţire ilicită, salvată de justiţie

August 14, 2022

Boris Johnson spotted in Greece on second holiday in two weeks

August 14, 2022

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest National Security News directly to your inbox.

© 2022 Estonian Free Press. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.